Although Jens Weidmann may have been alone on the ECB executive board in opposing yesterday’s ECB decision to buy government bonds, he looks to have the full-force of German public and media opinion right behind him. Over the last 24 hours, the German media, with surprisingly few exceptions, has fired a broadside against the ECB. No holds barred. Mario Draghi may have pleased markets, but he now has a very frustrated Germany – whose taxpayers are implicitly underwriting his institution (and the euro) – on his tail.
One of the most interesting reactions came from the Bundesbank itself, which unusually issued a public statement which ran directly contrary to the ECB’s decision. A Bundesbank spokesperson said:
Weidmann regarded the bond purchases “as being tantamount to financing governments by printing banknotes,” adding, “The announced interventions carry the additional danger that the central bank may ultimately redistribute considerable risks among various countries’ taxpayers.”
Süddeutsche Zeiting’s Marc Beise has a blistering piece, crediting “Weidmann’s persistent opposition” as the reason why the ECB is ‘only’ buying short-term debt. But, goes on to argue, “Saving the euro is worth a lot of effort but there are two important limitations. A euro rescue at any price can be a disaster economically, that is the red line that must not be exceeded. The other limit is the law: never in a rules based community can the end justify the means. A Euro-community based on breached contracts will always be based on fragile foundations. On Thursday, the ECB has unfortunately crossed both these red lines.”
Meanwhike, Die Welt led with the headline “Financial markets celebrate the death of the Bundesbank”, adding, “For Germany, the nightmare begins. There it was: the word that everyone was waiting for: unlimited…ECB President Draghi brazenly breaks with the principles of German monetary policy.” Bild runs with a similarly eye-catching headline, warning against “Draghi’s blank-cheque for debt-states”.
FAZ’s editor-in-chief Holger Steltzner also took a strong line, saying, “In the eurozone there isn’t any division any more between monetary and fiscal policy…We should be curious to hear what the German Constitutional Court thinks about that.”
The warning on the German Constitutional Court is an interesting one (a topic we’ll discuss in future posts) but some politicians went even further, with Hessen Europe Minister Jörg-Uwe Hahn of the FDP and CDU’s Klaus-Peter Willsch (already the initiator of one of the ESM complaints to the German Constitutional Court) calling for the German government to seriously consider taking the ECB to the European Court of Justice for violating its legal mandate.
The ECB wasn’t the only institution on the receiving end though, with the German government and Chancellor Merkel also taking flak. Handelsblatt’s deputy editor in chief, Florian von Kolf wrote, “Today is a black day for democracy…Merkel is silent…seemingly happy to have been partly relieved from her here Sisiphus task to save the euro”. DPA reports that SPD parliamentary leader Frank-Walter Steinmeier argued that the ECB’s decision is the “documentation of Chancellor Merkel’s failure…[while Weidmann] protests but Merkel gives the green light”, while the Green party decribed the CDU and FDP opposition as “hypocritical” since it was their failure to take any significant decisions on the crisis which forced the ECB to act.
We’ll continue to cover reaction throughout the day on the blog so stay tuned, but we can’t help but recall all those times we warned that saving the euro at any cost could drive a wedge between countries rather than bringing them closer together…Open Europe blog team